Boogie Board 8.5-Inch Stylus

I bought my kids some Boogie Boards for Christmas (http://a.co/8uhDFWl). It wasn't long before one of the styluses was lost, so I used the measurements from the one I had and created my first model in Tinkercad. Printing a cylindrical shape was a challenge; printing without supports failed. Printing with thin supports worked, but I had to do a fair amount of sanding, and it still doesn't look great, though. My kid loves it, and the other one keeps trying to lose her stylus so I can print her one