Large Tape Dispenser Insert

I have some large tape dispensers for big rolls of tape like masking or painter's tape and the smaller insert support broke. This is a replacement for that. I have a picture comparing it to the original (I have no idea what happened the axle on my print, the printer barfed or something, but it works so I'm not wasting plastic to reprint it). There are 2 versions, the smaller one fits snugly the opposite intended direction (with the parts sticking out on the inside not the outside), so I'm just using it as-is since it works. I did make another version that has a 0.5mm wider diameter, but I haven't printed it so I can't guarantee it fits.
Here is the tape dispenser set I got (I'm not necessarily recommending them, just for your reference): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0DMZYW9RB?ref_=ppx_hzsearch_conn_dt_b_fed_asin_title_6