Timer Knob for Pizza Oven

The timer knob broke on my pizza oven. I found this knob different than most oven type knobs as it uses a pin through a shaft rather than a flat on a shaft. See pictures. I printed with ABS because the front of my particular pizza oven gets kind of warm. PETG might be fine too. I'd probably not use PLA, but your mileage may vary. Provided two plates:Plate 1 prints in two pieces - I like this better - but I have printed both and both work. I printed in ABS, and I solvent welded the two pieces together by just wetting a cotton swab with acetone and swabbing the I.D. and O.D. then putting the pieces together. Plate 2 prints in one piece with supports. This works fine - but I'm not a fan.